Home etftrends.com Will ANTs spoil Mutual Funds’ Picnic?

Will ANTs spoil Mutual Funds’ Picnic?

Just what the world needs, more acronyms. While there isn’t yet an industry-agreed upon term, the active non-transparent (ANT) ETF structure is fresh and new. Non-transparent Active (NTA) might flow better, but it’s not as fun. Either way, the ETF industry has been waiting for some time for the launch of these specific type of ETF after the launch of the Exchange-Traded Managed Fund (ETMF) to limited success in 2014. Let’s look at why or why not these could be game changers in the industry (ETF 2.0 as some call it) and then examine the current structures and products.

The idea behind the non-transparent active ETF is fairly simple at a high level – soothe active managers worries about front-running and full transparency while still taking advantage of the benefits of the ETF structure. The hiding, scrambling, and delaying of those holdings is where the different proposed and approved structures come in. It seems as though many of the large active mutual fund managers are interested and learning and some are launching products in this space – which is great.

Content continues below advertisement

What are the benefits? The first, to me, is what I just mentioned – the lack of transparency that brings more top equity active managers to the ETF structure. From a structural standpoint, the tax savings could be substantial. As we know, ETFs are able to limit capital gains payouts due to the creation/redemption mechanism. Cost is another major benefit as many legacy active mutual funds can have fees well in excess of most ETFs, the ANT structure likely brings that down. However, there are many active mutual funds with institutional or retirement share classes with fees that do near those of many ETFs. Finally, the ability to transact intraday is a benefit of the structure, to some. I’m not sure if that’s all that important to long-term investors, but if that tradability helps the creation/redemption mechanism to work then it’s worth it for tax reasons.

It can’t all be good, right? There have to be drawbacks, and right now there are. First off there is no standardized structure or playbook, as there are several approved structures. Will one win out? Due to the way many of these products work, they need to disseminate a value every few seconds, therefore the underlying securities need to trade during the U.S. market hours. This limits the universe to mostly U.S. equities and Treasuries. One of the benefits of ETFs is access and liquidity brought to illiquid and hard to access asset classes. I’m sure someone will figure this out, but in the meantime, it doesn’t make these ANTs overwhelmingly exciting. After all, there has been evidence that active management brings more value to less covered and less liquid asset classes – those that aren’t eligible to be part of the structure, at least initially. The last worry I have is regarding trading. Each structure has little nuances that make it more difficult for market makers to be competitive with one another and benefit investors. You can see the early look at bid/ask spreads in the chart below. Also – this interaction between the fund and trading firms is vital to the tax efficiency of an ETF. If there’s any doubt that these active non-transparent ETFs can’t reduce the hefty tax bill that active managers have been sending to investors for years, they definitely lose a critical benefit.

Let’s take a look at the structures with products currently trading. It’s too early to make rash judgements about each, but definitely worth monitoring. We won’t go into the nuances between structures here, but feel free to click the links under “ANT type” to learn more.

Non/Semi-Transparent ETFsTickerANT Type Net AssetsMorningstar CategoryAverage SpreadExcess Return vs Category (Inception)Total Ret Inception (12/31/20)Inception Date
American Century Foc Dynmc Gr ETFFDGPrecidian $   216,853,387Large Growth0.13%27.9%85.9%3/31/2020
American Century Foc Lrg Cp Val ETFFLVPrecidian $   173,590,490Large Value0.17%-0.8%37.1%3/31/2020
American Century Mid Cap Growth Imp ETFMIDNYSE $       7,790,034Mid-Cap Growth0.16%0.4%30.5%7/15/2020
American Century Sustainable Equity ETFESGANYSE $   111,097,828Large Blend0.16%-1.4%17.3%7/15/2020
Clearbridge Focus Value ETFCFCVPrecidian $       3,164,032Large Value0.27%-1.4%22.4%5/27/2020
Fidelity® Blue Chip Growth ETFFBCGFidelity $   196,680,491Large Growth0.19%13.1%42.8%6/2/2020
Fidelity® Blue Chip Value ETFFBCVFidelity $     43,840,329Large Value0.18%-0.4%21.0%6/2/2020
Fidelity® New Millennium ETFFMILFidelity $     23,159,590Large Blend0.24%-1.8%22.2%6/2/2020
Natixis U.S. Equity Opportunities ETFEQOPNYSE $     11,959,392Large Blend0.13%3.4%14.8%9/16/2020
Natixis Vaughan Nelson Mid Cap ETFVNMCNYSE $       8,029,391Mid-Cap Blend0.17%-2.1%19.5%9/16/2020
Natixis Vaughan Nelson Select ETFVNSENYSE $       6,102,116Large Blend0.15%-1.7%9.7%9/16/2020
T. Rowe Price Blue Chip Growth ETFTCHPT. Rowe $     66,554,739Large Growth0.15%-3.6%12.3%8/4/2020
T. Rowe Price Dividend Growth ETFTDVGT. Rowe $     37,506,019Large Blend0.09%-1.6%13.5%8/4/2020
T. Rowe Price Equity Income ETFTEQIT. Rowe $     24,526,951Large Value0.15%1.8%19.0%8/4/2020
T. Rowe Price Growth Stock ETFTGRWT. Rowe $     26,232,720Large Growth0.12%1.0%16.8%8/4/2020
ETMFs
Eaton Vance Global Income Builder NS™EVGBCETMF $       6,664,764World Allocation0.22%1.5%9.5%3/30/2016
Eaton Vance Stock NextShares™EVSTCETMF $       7,528,707Large Blend0.17%1.0%16.8%2/25/2016
Eaton Vance TABS 5to15Yr Ldrd MuniBd NS™EVLMCETMF $       7,607,333Muni National Interm0.21%0.7%3.8%3/30/2016

ETFs have had an amazing year of inflows – capturing more than $500 Billion of assets – a lot of that coming from traditional mutual funds. Active Non-transparent ETFs captured nearly $1 Billion, not too shabby for only a few months of a new structure in the marketplace – but still a long way to go to fully displace and disrupt active mutual funds. New transparent entrants into the active ETF world have also thrown a wrench into the equation. Dimensional Fund Advisors (DFA) converted several of their tax-efficient mutual funds to ETFs, and transparent, concentrated, active funds managed by ARK Invest have taken the fund world by storm with incredible 2020 returns and massive inflows. No matter how you slice it, the future is bright for ETFs, and its exciting to be part of. Here’s to improving investor outcomes even more in 2021.

newETFs.io respects the hard work of others and gives all credit to the remarkable folks at ETFTrends.com. This excerpt/article was pulled from their RSS feed; click here to view the original. Please note that on occasion, the RSS feed will not have the author. When this happens this site defaults the author to "News". Make no mistake, this excerpt/article was not created by newETFs.io, it was simply shared with you.